DispatchTrack Blog

Useful news for last mile logistics operators.

Manual vs. Automated Route Planning: Why Automation Changes Everything

Share this article
Dec 15, 2020

Fleet managers are faced with new challenges every single day. Changing customer demands and shorter lead times have made route planning more complex than ever. Balancing competitive service levels and cost-efficient deliveries is a tough job these days, due to aggressive competition.

Route Planning Automation

Improving delivery performance in all aspects is necessary to survive and stand out among the competition. But businesses that remain attached to manual route planning are unlikely to see an improvement in speed, predictability, and accuracy of deliveries.

Manual routing should be a thing of the past. Sadly, this isn’t the case, as many fleet owners and managers still prefer manually planning the routes, failing to realize that manual route planning hurts the business’ competitiveness and performance.

Fleet managers and owners must ask themselves if it is really possible to plan routes using sheets and to provide customers with realistic and accurate ETAs. Is it cost-effective to assign routes according to the drivers’ preferences?

Manually entering details in an Excel sheet and having planners plot the delivery schedule for the next day may have once worked. But times are different, and manual planning is now a key contributor to expensive operational inefficiencies. We look at the major limitations of manual route planning and explain why automation is essential for your business’ success.

Manual Route Planning: The Main Disadvantages

Reduced Fleet Performance

Route planning isn’t as simple as assigning drivers to deliveries. It goes beyond that, as effective route planning must account for different variables.

Unfortunately, a human’s brain cannot juggle all variables needed for optimal route planning, especially when multiple vehicles are supposed to stop at multiple delivery points. Failure to account for various road variables means trucks going from one point to another needlessly, resulting in constant delays, missed deliveries, and disgruntled customers.

Competitive Challenges

Thanks to giants like Amazon, customers now want quick deliveries, real-time visibility on the packages, proactive alerts, and the ability to communicate with delivery drivers. Thus, businesses that want to thrive must possess the same competitive advantages that industry giants have.

Quick and accurate deliveries aren’t just for those that intend to go head-to-head with the likes of Amazon or Walmart. Other businesses will do well to offer the same delivery services of retail giants, too.

For example, a drug-delivery service provider must deliver the pharmaceuticals on time or the patient could miss taking his or her prescribed drugs. Likewise, a supplier of fresh produce will also reap benefits if it can show that it can deliver during the hours specified by the grocery store.

It will be hard to retain loyal customers if the business cannot deliver quickly or if it misses the customers’ preferred time windows. It’s also hard to win new clients when one doesn’t have KPIs showing that the business is capable of sticking to agreed delivery timeframes. Unfortunately, manual route planning cannot generate handy figures that would impress prospective clients.

Diminished Profits

Enterprises that aim to grow should brace themselves for more operational complexities. Having more customers is always a good thing, but growing the business and sticking to manual route planning is a recipe for disaster.

Sure, enterprises can always add more drivers and vehicles to their fleet as they grow their business, but are the additions necessary? Purchasing vehicles and hiring more drivers also means higher operating costs that can drain away whatever profits can be generated by the expansion.

Business expansion without an efficient routing system tends to end up in chaos. The dispatch team will be dealing with a larger volume of orders, drivers, and vehicles, while manually plotting the best routes and assigning drivers to delivery points. And chaos in operations always drags one’s profits.

Automated Route Planning is Key to Operational Excellence

There are many factors involved in determining the most optimal routes, including truck and driver availability, customer location, quantities, dock restriction, delivery times, and maintenance schedules, just to name a few. Manual route planning simply cannot consider all these variables, but an automated route planner can. This means drivers can take the most optimal routes to ensure efficiency and accuracy in their deliveries.

One might have years of experience in manually planning and tracking routes, but the mind can only take in so much information all at once. On the other hand, a sophisticated route planning solution can deal with hundreds or even thousands of delivery points, drivers, and variables all at once, something that human dispatchers and planners can’t.

Providing drivers with efficient routes every single day means cutting down on fuel costs, which is the second biggest expense in fleet operations. Likewise, less distance traveled by the vehicles also means saving on vehicle maintenance costs.

Automated route planning is essential in maintaining loyal customers and acquiring new ones as well. A sophisticated route planner allows for faster delivery times and accurate delivery windows. Dispatchers can make last-minute changes according to real-time road and weather conditions, helping companies avoid costly missed deliveries. This helps create a seamless customer experience and generate positive feedback.

There are hundreds of variables that must be factored into route planning. Unfortunately, not even the most seasoned dispatchers or planners can account or plan for all of these variables every single day and at all times of day. And the complexity in route planning doesn’t end with these variables, as businesses also have to consider how their failure to deliver quickly and on time can impact customer satisfaction and expansion plans. It’s time to accept that manual route planning has come to its end and automation is the way forward.


DispatchTrack offers the most powerful end-to-end suite of tools for last mile logistics operators. Dispatchers, drivers, customers and clients can access our app on any device to schedule, track, modify and verify your deliveries.

See how DispatchTrack can optimize your operation

EXPLORE OUR COMPANY

Product Offerings →

A tool for every job. Be it routing, billing, or customer management, we can help your business be better.

Calculate Your ROI →

Most of our clients see ROI the first 30 days. See what you could save.

Meet The Team →

What does it take to make a team work? Leadership, experience, and a unified vision of where the company is headed.

See DispatchTrack's Last Mile Optimization Capabilities in Action

How an Efficient Route Planner Improves Delivery Management

May 21, 2021

Manual route planning is time-consuming. It can be challenging enough for human planners to work with a few delivery vehicles and...

4 Things to Look for in a Delivery Route Planning App

Feb 8, 2021

Manually planning drivers' routes often results in lost time and inaccuracies—sure, you might be able to find the best route by...

5 Benefits of the Right Route Planning App

Jun 17, 2021

It’s hard to imagine now, but there was a time when drivers would stop and roll down their windows to ask strangers for...

Learn More About DispatchTrack

DispatchTrack offers shippers a feature-rich platform designed to boost last-mile visibility and help delight customers